Modern monetary theory: A historical retrospective

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu05.2022.304

Abstract

This article examines applied aspects of Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). Currently, this theory has gained popularity in wide academic circles and is the subject of wide discourse among both theoretical economists and practical economists. Scholars evaluate this theory ambiguously, and many researchers believe its main provisions are divorced from economic realities, contradictory and, therefore, not acceptable as instruments of macroeconomic policy. The author believes that the use of retrospective analysis could be productive for the verification of certain provisions of the MMT. The use of the historical experience of monetary circulation, in which similar principles were used, certainly has significant research potential. The article discusses the fundamental provisions of the MMT related to the peculiarities of the functioning of fiat money systems in a historical context. Knapp, creating his state theory of money, also relied on the Russian experience of paper-money circulation. In the presented work, using examples taken from Russian economic history, it is shown how monetary policy instruments similar to those proposed by MMT were used in the real economy. In particular, the history of the first Russian paper money-banknotes is considered. The Russian experience of paper-money circulation can be considered quite successful, because thanks to them, the financial situation of the country was quite stable, the national economy was actively developing. An important circumstance was that the models of monetary administration in Russia were applied creatively, and not dogmatically scrupulously. This is the way to approach the use of MMT in the modern Russian economy, which is under unprecedented sanctions.

Keywords:

assignats, modern monetary theory, banknotes, sovereign money, paper money

Downloads

 

References

Литература

Андрюшин, С. А. (2020) ‘Деньги — это творение государства или рынка? (О «современной денежной теории», изложенной в учебнике У. Митчелла, Л. Р. Рея и М. Уоттса «Макроэкономика»)’, Вопросы экономики, (6), с. 121–134.

Бурлачков, В. К. (2021) ‘«Современная денежная теория»: используемые методы анализа и парадоксальность выводов’, Вопросы экономики, (3), с. 152–159.

Гребенников, П. А. (2019) ‘«Двойная спираль» рыночной экономики’, Финансы и бизнес, 4 (15), с. 3–22.

Грищенко, В., Остапенко, В., Ткачев, В. и Тунёв В. (2021) ‘Современная денежная теория (ММТ): новая парадигма или набор рекомендаций для макроэкономической политики?’, Экономическая политика, 3 (16), с. 8–43.

Дубянский, А. Н. (2012) ‘Простонародные лажи в денежном обращении России в начале XIX века’, ЭКО, (10), с. 179–188.

Дубянский, А. Н. (2013) ‘Категория параллельных денег в русской экономической литературе XIX—XX веков’, Вопросы экономики, (7), с. 111–123.

Дубянский, А. Н. (2015) ‘Государственная теория денег Г. Кнаппа: история и современные перспективы’, Вопросы экономики, (3), с. 109–125.

Дубянский, А. Н. (2020) ‘Философский взгляд на деньги (О книге У. Бьерга «Как делаются деньги? Философия посткредитного капитализма»)’, Вопросы экономики,(3), с. 129–140.

Лакатос, И. (2008) Избранные произведения по философии и методологии науки. Пер. И. Веселовского, В. Поруса, А. Никифорова. М.: Академический проспект; Трикста.

Моисеев С. Р. (2019) ‘Хайп вокруг (не)денежной (не)теории’, Вопросы экономики, (9), с. 112–122.

Ческидов, Б. М. (2021) ‘Антикризисные аспекты современной денежной теории’, Вопросы экономики, (7), с. 152–160.

Юхт, А. И. (1994) Русские деньги от Петра Великого до Александра I. М.: Финансы и статистика.

Bell, S. (2001) ‘The role of the state and the hierarchy of money,’ Cambridge Journal of Economics, 25 (2),pp. 149–163.

Kahan, A. (1966) ‘The cost of “westernization” in Russia: The gentry and the economy in the eighteenth century’, Slavic Review, XXV (1), pp. 62–89.

Krugman, P. (2019) ‘Running on MMT (wonkish)’, The New York Times, February 25.

Mankiw, G. (2019) ‘A Skeptic’s guide to modern monetary theory’, Harvard University Working Paper, December 12.

Mitchell, W. (1998) ‘The buffer stock employment model and the NAIRU: The path to full Employment’, Journal of Economic Issues, 32 (2), pp. 547–555.

Mitchell, W. and Connors, L. (2020) ‘Capitalism on life support’, Working Paper, no. 20-03. Centre of Full Employment and Equity The University of Newcastle, Callaghan NSW 2308, Australia.

Mitchell, W., Wray. L. R. and Watts, M. (2019) Macroeconomics. London: Red Globe Press.

Nesiba, R. (2013) ‘Do institutionalists and post-Keynesians share a common approach to Modern Monetary Theory (MMT)?’, European Journal of Economics and Economic Policies: Intervention, 10 (1), pp. 44–60.

Rogoff, K. (2019) ‘Modern monetary nonsense’, Project Syndicate, March 4. URL: https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/federal-reserve-modern-monetary theorydangers-by-kenneth-rogoff-2019-03(дата обращения: 10.02.2022).

Tymoigne, É. and Wray, L. R. (2013) ‘Modern money theory 101: A reply to critics’, Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, November Working Paper, no. 778

Wray, L. R. (2020) ‘The “Kansas City” approach to modern money theory’, Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, Working Paper, no. 961.

Wray, L. R. (1999) ‘An irreverent overview of the history of money from the beginning of the beginning through to the present’, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 21 (4), рр. 679–687.


References

Andryushin, S. A. (2020) ‘Is money the creation of the state or the market? (On the “modern monetary theory” as described in the textbook by W. Mitchell, L. R. Wray and M. Watts “Macroeconomics”)’, Voprosy ekonomiki, (6), pp. 121–134. (In Russian)

Bell, S. (2001) ‘The role of the state and the hierarchy of money,’ Cambridge Journal of Economics, 25 (2), pp. 149–163.

Burlachkov, V. K. (2021) ‘Modern Monetary Theory: Methods of analysis used and paradoxical conclusions’, Voprosy ekonomiki, (3), pp. 152–159. (In Russian)

Cheskidov, B. M. (2021) ‘Anti-recessionary aspects of the modern monetary theory’, Voprosy ekonomiki, (7), pp. 152–160. (In Russian)

Dubyanskiy, A. (2012) ‘Common People’s lages in the monetary circulation of Russia at the beginning of the 19th Century’, ECO, (10), pp. 179–188. (In Russian)

Dubyanskiy, A. (2013) ‘Parallel money in the Russian economic literature of the 19th–20th centuries’, Voprosy ekonomiki, (7), pp. 111–123. (In Russian)

Dubyanskiy, A. (2015) ‘G. Knapp’s state theory of money: History and current perspectives’, Voprosy ekonomiki, (3), pp. 109–125. (In Russian)

Dubyanskiy, A. N. (2020) ‘Philosophical perspective on money (On the book by O. Bjerg “Making money. The philosophy of crisis capitalism”)’, Voprosy ekonomiki, (3), pp. 129–140. (In Russian)

Grebennikov, P. I. (2019) ‘The double helix of a market economy’, Finance and Business, 15 (4), pp. 3–22. (In Russian)

Grishchenko, V., Ostapenko, V., Tkachev, V. and Tunyov, V. (2021) ‘Modern monetary theory (MMT): New paradigm or a set of recommendations for macroeconomic policy’, Economic Policy, 16 (3), pp. 8–43.(In Russian)

Jukht, A. I. (1994) Russian money from Peter the Great to Alexander I. Moscow: Finansy i statistika Publ. (In Russian)

Kahan, A. (1966) ‘The cost of “westernization” in Russia: The gentry and the economy in the eighteenth century’, Slavic Review, XXV (1), pp. 62–89.

Krugman, P. (2019) ‘Running on MMT (wonkish)’, The New York Times, 25 February.

Lakatos, I. (2008) Proofs and refutations. History of science and its rational reconstructions. Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes. Rus. ed. Moscow: Akademicheskii prospekt Publ.; Triksta Publ. (In Russian)

Mankiw, G. (2019) ‘A skeptic’s guide to modern monetary theory’, Harvard University Working Paper, December 12.

Mitchell, W. (1998) ‘The buffer stock employment model and the NAIRU: The path to full Employment’, Journal of Economic Issues, 32 (2), pp. 547–555.

Mitchell, W. and Connors, L. (2020) ‘Capitalism on life support,’ Working Paper, no. 20-03. Centre of Full Employment and Equity the University of Newcastle, Callaghan NSW 2308, Australia.

Mitchell W., Wray. L. R. and Watts, M. (2019) Macroeconomics. London: Red Globe Press.

Moiseev, S. R. (2019) ‘Hype around (non)monetary (non)theory’, Voprosy ekonomiki, (9), pp. 112–122. (In Russian)

Nesiba, R. (2013) ‘Do institutionalists and post-Keynesians share a common approach to modern monetary theory (MMT)?’, European Journal of Economics and Economic Policies: Intervention, 10 (1), pp. 44–60.

Rogoff, K. (2019) ‘Modern monetary nonsense’, Project Syndicate, March 4. Available at: https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/federal-reserve- modernmonetary-theorydangers-by-kennethrogoff-2019-03 (accessed: 10.02.2022).

Tymoigne, É. and Wray, L. R. (2013) ‘Modern money theory 101: A reply to critics,’ Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, November Working Paper, no. 778.

Wray, L. R. (1999) ‘An irreverent overview of the history of money from the beginning of the beginning through to the present’, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 21 (4), рр. 679–687.

Wray, L. R. (2020) ‘The “Kansas City” approach to modern money theory’, Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, Working Paper, no. 961.

Published

2022-09-17

How to Cite

Dubyanskiy, A. . . (2022). Modern monetary theory: A historical retrospective. St Petersburg University Journal of Economic Studies, 38(3), 416–435. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu05.2022.304

Issue

Section

Economic history and the history of economic thought